Former Miss Universe Malaysia Dragged Online For Tone Deaf Comments On Black Lives Matter


Subscribe to our new Telegram channel for the latest updates on Covid-19 and other issues.
As the Black Lives Matter protests in the United States continues along with a global movement on the realities of oppression and racism against black people, a former Miss Universe Malaysia has sparked outrage over her tone-deaf comments on the matter.
Samantha Katie James, who was crowned Miss Universe Malaysia in 2017 and largely known for wearing the nasi lemak dress, took to Instagram to share her views on the redundancy of violent protests.
While that sentiment alone isn’t controversial, things took a strange twist when the Malaysian of Chinese and Brazilian heritage wrote a message to black people, advising them to “relax” and “take it as a challenge”.
She continued to say that they “chose to be born as a coloured person in America” and to “accept it as it is”.

Bewildered Malaysians who came across her message wrote back, some seeking clarification, some heated over her comments and some explaining the realities of systemic oppression of being a black person.

However, the ex-beauty queen’s responses include saying that she’s been insulted all her life for being a white girl in a local Malaysian school and that she refuses to generate anger.


Her baffling responses have since gathered steam online with the topics “Samantha” and “Miss Universe Malaysia” trending on Twitter.
"Why does my baby have a hole in her heart? She always turns blue and hasn't gained weight."
— Dr Jason Leong (@DrJasonLeong) June 1, 2020
Doctor : Well, often there is no genetic or environmental cause.
Samantha Kay, Miss Universe Malaysia 2017 : Your baby chose to be born with a hole in her heart.#BlackLivesMatter pic.twitter.com/icLMgmLC1q
This y’alls miss universe malaysia??? pic.twitter.com/XRsQM0nLbC
— HEAD BARB IN CHARGE (@lilasianthiccie) June 1, 2020
Not Miss Universe Malaysia spiritually gaslighting black people "you chose to be born as a 'coloured' person in America for a reason. To learn a lesson."
— XO (@arebirthofvenus) June 1, 2020
I— https://t.co/awA5YdPTXO
Dethrone miss universe Malaysia she’s an embarrassment to carry that title
— HOESTAZAH NIK MINHAJ (@mabitxch) June 1, 2020
this what the Miss Universe Malaysia sees when shes being born pic.twitter.com/7x9TwQKMKo
— melon cat (@ilhisma) June 1, 2020
tf how the hell did she ever become miss universe malaysia. WHITE PRIVILEGE AT ITS FINEST.“we all ok only”no WE ARE NOT OKAY but this is not bout us,this is bout using ur voice to speak for the ppl of the black community.Cause their lives are in danger. HOW CAN THIS NOT BOTHER U? pic.twitter.com/tjTiGIROT2
— wh.tsername (@larissalorelle) June 1, 2020
Samantha is likely alluding to a Hindu karmic belief where a soul chooses its life and circumstances in order to learn the lesson for liberation. However, what she was trying to relay may have been lost in translation, lacking in context and perhaps an understanding on other people’s circumstances.
TRP has reached out to her for comment and still awaiting her reply at the time of writing.
While discussing the nuances of being black in America, along with its complexities is out of our depth, we’ll let South African comedian and political commentator in the US, Trevor Noah explain it in the emotional video below:
Share your thoughts with us on TRP’s Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.

She puts the pun in Punjabi. With a background in healthcare, lifestyle writing and memes, this lady's articles walk a fine line between pun-dai and pun-ishing.